jump to navigation

Erin Watches Simoun (and apparently Has A Lot Of Feelings) July 16, 2011

Posted by Erin Ptah in Meta.
Tags: , ,
trackback

I just finished watching Simoun (info: Wikipedia, TVTropes), and I feel a serious need to complain.

The setup: In the world of the series, humans are all born female-sexed, and remain that way throughout childhood. There’s a magical/holy spring in the country of Simulacrum that citizens visit at age 17, where they choose the adult sex they’re going to grow into (with male and female being the only options). Also, there’s a war on, and the magical/holy aircraft used to fight it (the titular Simoun) can only be piloted by youths who haven’t chosen their adult sex yet, which has led to a couple of pilots (called Sibyllae, a type of priestess) putting off going to the Spring so they can keep fighting in the meantime.

This sounds like a jumping-off point for all kinds of fascinating exploration of sex and gender and sexuality, and all the recs I’ve seen have raved about the way it plays with and subverts and is generally nifty about those issues. And…well.

(Spoilers ahead.)

Note: For simplicity’s sake, I’m going to use “men” and “women” to refer to adults (i.e., acting as if they’re all cis — that’s not necessarily the case, but more on that later), and “girls” to refer to anyone who hasn’t gone to the Spring (they haven’t necessarily settled on a gender identity, or may have settled on a non-female one, but they’re socially constructed as girls and all seem comfortable referring to themselves that way).

So, okay, the first thing that seems obvious about a world like this is that there shouldn’t be sexism. At least, not any kind of sexism that we would recognize. Adult men can’t tell themselves that women are inferior, because all the women they know could have been men if they had made a different choice at the Spring. Little girls aren’t judged in comparison to little boys, because there is no such thing. Nobody has to disclose (or even settle on!) a choice of adult sex until age 17, leaving plenty of time to demonstrate their capabilities before anyone has a chance to judge them based on sex or gender.

But as the series progresses, little things about the background characters start to add up. Like how all the regular soldiers (as opposed to the Sibyllae) seem to be men. Or any time you see a group of politicians…men. High-ranking diplomats…men. Mechanics…men. One major character who works on the Simoun looks female, but that’s because he was only recently at the Spring, and his body hasn’t finished changing (it’s not an instant process). There are no actual women in any major roles in these positions, and an awful lot of scenes where women aren’t apparent even in the background.

It’s not just an oversight by the animators, either. When talking about a group of people going to the Spring, someone says “The ones who were set to inherit family businesses became men, and for the rest it was pretty random.” Either women are legally prohibited from inheriting businesses (which makes no sense in our world, let alone this one), or the traits that you would need to run a business are only present in people who choose to become men (which is freakishly stereotypical at the best of times).

Other dialogue reinforces this idea that characteristics and interests that would have developed long before age 17 are associated with being a man. Sibyllae will say things like “I want to become a man so I can protect you” or “I was thinking of becoming a man and tinkering around in the shop with you.” The finale does manage to give us a woman in coveralls, hard at work hauling boxes (while pregnant!), which is like a breath of fresh air…although it’s in the same scene as the male boss being asked what he wants his wife to make him for dinner.

Speaking of the finale, lemme talk about Floe for a second. Floe is an adorably girlish Sibylla, who’s all about pouting and hairbows and flirting with young men. (There’s an anime trope for this, right? The cute bubbly girl with big poufy hair who says “Hmph!” a lot?) The flirting included the assurance “Don’t worry, I’m planning to become a woman,” but there are a couple of hints along the way that it might go otherwise, and by the time of the trip to the Spring, Floe decides to become a man. It sounds like the embodiment of every “FTM Bubbles Utonium” prompt ever.

Then we get to see Floe as a man (name changed to Floef, as per local convention). His hair is chopped short, he’s a tanned and muscular farmer in rough clothing, and he’s determined to find a cute wife one day. The implication being that his youthful interests weren’t because he was Floe — a person who enjoys having long pretty hair and is attracted to cute guys — but because he was a girl, or maybe a child, and now that he’s an adult/man he’s only presented as doing things that are adult/manful.

I just. What is that supposed to subvert? I was promised subversion.

The association of girlishness with childishness…actually, come to think of it, maybe this could be an explanation for the sexism in Simoun-land: they have no cultural template for male immaturity. There are no teenage boys crashing their parents’ cars, no toddler boys that need to be potty-trained, no middle school boys starting food fights in the cafeteria. If all children appear to be female, then it’s visually easier to associate adult women with childish traits, and something so pervasive could definitely be the foundation of society-wide biases.

…but that interpretation wasn’t even hinted at, much less interrogated, in the canon itself. Alas.

(Although it does make slightly more sense out of the commander who says “Even though I don’t look it, I used to be a Sibylla.” Said commander is a man; the implication is “I don’t look like I used to be a girl.” Which makes no sense, because according to the show’s biology, everyone used to be a girl.)

What we get instead is, first off, a reframing of the whole war that seems bizarre on other levels as well as gender. Toward the end, the country of Simulacrum loses the war and is taken over; one condition of the peace treaty is that the Sibyllae all go to the Spring, to render them unable to pilot the Simoun as part of a resistance. They’re pretty conflicted, to say the least. Because it’s a term of surrender? Because they’ll be cut off forever from a hard-won skill? Because they’re balking at the idea of having to pin down a gender identity enough to choose a sex? Not according to this exchange between two of them: “Are you scared?” “Of course! Growing up is always scary!”

Keep in mind, these girls are war pilots. They’ve been putting their lives on the line to protect the people of their country. Some of them have seen the effects of the war in their own home towns. They’ve killed, and some of them have died; one was gunned down in full view of her colleagues. In one episode they met a foreign priestess acting as a diplomat, who, after they had started to develop a sense of camaraderie with her as a not-so-different-after-all fellow priestess, turned out to be a suicide bomber.

But none of that counts as “growing up”! Oh no no no, growing up means giving up all this gender-ambiguous nonsense and picking one side on the gender binary and sticking with it.

The fact that it also means losing the ability to pilot adds a whole new level of thematic creepiness. It makes their service in combat feel about as consequential as Floe’s hair ribbons: a childish thing, to be put away when you become an adult.

It’s more than a little reminiscent of the whole premise of Class S yuri, in which schoolgirls form deep and emotionally intense bonds that are nevertheless expected to be just a phase, to be exchanged for “real” straight romances later in life.

The parallel gets completely unsubtle when you take into account one of the yuri hooks of the series: each Simoun has two pilots, who start its motor running by…kissing. Again, this sounds like an awesome premise! Magical flying robots powered by lesbianism. Except. Except that the only kisses that work are between girls who haven’t “grown up” yet. And when it comes to relationships between adults, they are, almost without exception, male/female. Floe says “It’s okay, I’m going to become a woman” to cute guys; Floef dreams of having a cute wife. Several young people express the dream of finding their chosen person and going to the Spring together, to come out one as a woman and one as a man. Of the two apparently f/f couples that do endure (Neveril/Aeru and Limone/Dominura), it’s between people who haven’t gone to the Spring.

The Simoun aren’t powered by lesbianism. They’re powered by Class-S. The universe’s whole biology works as a way to institutionalize Class-S relationships among teenagers, while assuring us that it’s okay, all the adults are still straight.

Okay, one semi-exception: there’s a yaoi-bait pair of guys among the adult cast. According to TVTropes’ report of the director’s commentary, “when they where Sibyllae, they both decided to end up together, but when they went to The Spring, they both assumed that the other would be the woman.” Which, honestly, could be comedic gold, except that it fits right into the pattern of no adult same-sex couples getting any romance that isn’t subtext. And when you think about it seriously, it raises some unsettling questions: did they both want to be men? Or did they both independently decide to live out their lives as [an approximate local analogue of] non-op trans women in order to be with the person they loved? And just how much anti-gay pressure would it take to push someone to such a decision?

(Guess how much of that was addressed, or even hinted at, in-series. No, go on, guess.)

The show does end up sending a few mixed messages about whether going to the Spring is an absolute necessity. Even though it’s described as “growing up” for most of the Sibyllae, it was forced on them as part of a surrender treaty. Then, when Neveril and Aeru hijack the last Simoun and skip out (not to mount a resistance, just to Fly Free Forever), it’s presented as a triumph. (Note: Limone and Dominura aren’t part of the group when the treaty happens; they ditched the whole thing via time travel. When we last see them, Limone’s still piloting but doesn’t look old enough for the Spring anyway; Dominura’s given up flying, but it’s not clear whether she’s gone to the Spring, or plans to.)

On the other hand, their whole “hooray eternal youth and yuri and mad piloting skillz!” theme is undercut by the guardian of the Spring: an ancient apparently-female entity who, it is revealed, refused to choose an adult sex and was eventually cursed to stay there and guard the place for all eternity. One of the remaining Sibyllae elects to take up the post, freeing the original guardian (to die, that is; after however many centuries, it appears to be a relief, but it’s still a raw deal). Are Neveril and Aeru doomed to be hit by a similar curse? And if not, then why did it happen to this guardian? I’m honestly not sure what the viewer is supposed to think about that one.

Nor am I sure what we’re supposed to think about a massive issue that gets raised all the way back in episode four, and then never raised again. Two of the Sibyllae crash-land in a forest and spend a while being captured by a single foreign soldier, who reveals that his country doesn’t have a holy/magic Spring. (The Sibyllae don’t speak his language; it’s the audience who gets to hear it.) Their biology is the same, with all babies born female-bodied but capable of growing into either female or male adult bodies; to get men in their society, half of the babies are altered using hormones and surgery from birth.

This is huge. Unless their science has come up with some way to predict the gender identity of infants, these people have got to be picking sexes pretty much at random. What kind of gender dynamics does that lead to? Also, it means the odds are that something like half the population is trans — not only that, but avoidably trans, at least for those who identify as simply male/female, if only they had access to Simulacrum’s Spring. And if they have established procedures for changing the bodies of infants, couldn’t those procedures be adapted for adults who want to undo some or all of it…and could those same procedures then be used on adults from Simulacrum who weren’t happy with what the Spring had given them? (In other words: what do the genderqueer people think about this?) Basically, how do these wildly different constructions of sex influence their respective societies, and how does each of them change by coming in contact with the other? And come to think of it, are all babies unambiguously female-bodied, or is there a local analogue to intersex people — and if not, why not (magic?) — and if so, how are they treated, and, and, and…

…and guess how much of this gets so much as mentioned at any point during the rest of the series.

Honestly, what I’d like to read right now is some detailed dissection of the gender issues from Simoun‘s fans. I’ve seen people rave about them, but in vague or brief or edited-for-spoilers ways — which I did appreciate before seeing the series, but now that there’s nothing left to spoil, it would be nice to know if there are things I’m missing, or if we’re just reading the same events differently.

But for the moment, as far as I’m concerned, the show was a fascinating premise turned into a frustrating pileup of missed opportunities.

(Note to anyone who’s thinking of watching it after reading this post: the only warning-worthy content I can think of that hasn’t already been mentioned is the surprise!rapist!sister in episode 12, with a side of “well, maybe you led her on” from a confidante. The incident itself is limited to a couple of vague flashes — which, for the record, is more on-screen action than any other same-sex pairing gets.)

Advertisements

Comments»

1. seagullsong - July 16, 2011

Actually, I was thinking of watching it *until* I read this post. It seems like…if they’re not going to address any of those issues, what’s the point of inventing the whole magic spring concept? Why do we care?

Erin Ptah - July 16, 2011

Heh, yeah, it wasn’t exactly a rec ^_^; But I figure some people will want to see it for themselves before deciding whether they agree with my judgment.

We care because it lets us eat our Class-S cake and have our straightness too, that’s why. (Bitter yuri fan is bitter.)

2. FilledeMarius - July 16, 2011

Floe sounds like a mix of Odango Hair and Hair of Gold, as far as tropes go. As you said, it doesn’t seem to be a very widely known series and the opinions shown here vary. http://myanimelist.net/anime/879/Simoun/reviews&p=1 A quick Internet search didn’t turn up anything except for that and several AMVs, but there might be a community on LJ for it; it wouldn’t hurt checking.

3. X - July 20, 2011

Ugh. Simoun. I watched the 1st ep when it originally came out. I was turned off by the art style and the blatantly pandering hook. “Magical flying machines powered by kissing girls! Watch me, fanboys!” Glad to know I didn’t miss much.

Best thing I got from this post is the definition of Class S. So THAT’S what the genre is called. I was aware of it from a cultural perspective (homosexuality is seen as fundamentally immature behavior to be outgrown if it’s indulged in), but not the name. The related Western cultural more is summed up as: “Lesbian acts are acceptable only insomuch as the females’ eventual willingness to copulate with a man.”

4. Wolfie - November 16, 2011

Regarding Onashia, she was more or less sentenced to the springs not just due to the fact that she didn’t choose a gender. She never had the chance to complete the Emerald Rimajon and achieve “Eternal Maiden” status “Eien no Miko”. (I do a yearly rewatch of the series so the dialogue is more or less fresh in my mind LOL). Priestesses/Pairs who perform a perfect Emerald have to be of sound mind as well as have the same goal to be considered a “true pair” to make the rimajons work (something that Floe also pointed out mid-series)

The series was more about the character’s reactions toward the war, their interactions with each other and about making choices…actually the latter would be the main point as the director had mentioned in a staff commentary. Although in Aaeru and Neviril’s case, they were forced to make a decision thus chose to rebel. But their Sugioku no Rimajon actually worked perfectly (as theirs produced a bright white light while the Emerald from ep 1 and Dominura/Rimone’s version produced a pitch black vacuum)

However going back to Dominura and Rimone…neither one has gone to the spring yet. Rimone is about 17 in episode 26 according to the character designer (Nishima Asako) which would make Dominura about 24. she was feeling the effects of not going to the spring which would have been remedied if they had decided to fly off a lot sooner than what we had seen of them in the last episode. Remember they decided to fly again at the conclusion of their final scene as Dominura (dressed in their pilot uniform) had asked Rimone what sky she would like to fly to next. From that point, viewers are to assume they took off via Emerald Rimajon once again. And Dominura would not have even given it a second thought if she had gone to the spring since you cannot be a priestess anymore the minute you’ve chosen a gender or a gender had been selected for you.

For Floe to become Floeff…I don’t know, somehow I thought that was fitting. She was a really fickle and didn’t know what she wanted in life plus viewers already had assumed that she was going to remain female. I was shocked by some of their choices but I like that kind of shock. It keeps the viewers on their toes (or at least me) and most of what we had speculated during the original broadcast back in 2006 were completely wrong which meant that this series wasn’t as predictable as we had thought.

As much as I love Yuri, that theme didn’t suck me in to this series. As a viewer, I stuck by the series wondering constantly what kind of choices these girls would make. The series, in my eyes was a coming of age piece about either going with the social norm (well Simulacrum’s norm) or fighting against that social norm and choosing what you feel is right for you instead of hearing from the mouths of other what’s “supposed” to be right.

In some ways, this series reminds me of what it was like for me living in Japan a few years ago. Sexism is so prevalent there and because it is such a collective mind-set in Japan, not many people would stand up for others who choose to rebel against their social norms . Aaeru and Neviril chose to rebel against the Simulacrum’s collective mind-set and didn’t want to be forced into a decision while the other girls finally gave in and become part of that norm. However, a few of them, while still part of that society found rewarding and selfless opportunities to help parentless victims of the war (Parietta and Rodearomon).

Anyhow, this series has always been a hard sell but it is definitely one of my favorite series to date. Been a fan of it since ’06 and still going strong. But yeah, I can see how people can be turned off by some of the ideals in the show. I somehow had a difficult time selling this idea to my male friends but my straight female friends seemed to be sucked into the storyline (LOL). My fellow bisexual gal pals were turned off by the 1st episode until one of them decided to trudge past that episode. Now it’s one of her favorite series as well. Once again, this is a series that won’t appeal to the masses but it does have its share of followers though we’re pretty miniscule in the English speaking world.

In Japan it was only sleeper hit back in 2006 and didn’t generate enough sales because many of the male fandom were just turned off by avante garde. This series was an experiment during that time and a labor of love between the director Nishimura Junji and the character designer Nishida Asako (whose work I immensely love) and they went in knowing that it was risky.

Surprisingly enough the fandom arose again just recently in Japan(well technically in February of this year 2011) and they re-released the series as a collectors set. As a result, the original radio show “Simoun Denpa De Rimajon” featuring Takahashi Rieko-san and Takahashi Mikako-san (Neviril and Rodoreamon respectively) was revived for that month. Those sales were pretty decent though I doubt anymore will be done with that franchise aside from the 2 manga adaptations and PS2 game)

Phew, I said quite a bit, LOL…sorry about that. Just sharing some of my love for the series but attempting to understand how other viewers see the series. It’s interesting to see other people’s perspectives. I came from a forum long ago where at least 85-90% of us had praise for the series while other rest had disdain. Regardless of the arguments and debates that went on, people actually talked about the series so at least there was an interest in it. It’s when people stop talking about it that the series leaves little to no impact. I was genuinely happy to come across your post and see that there were still people viewing and reviewing the series regardless of what side of the coin they fall on. Whether people like or hate the series, I got a feeling it will be discussed for ages….or that’s just the optimist in me LOL (Not too many Gen-Xer females like me that see the glass as half full Hahahaha)

But I guess I’ll end it here. Anyhow, best regards and nice blog!
–Wolfie

Erin Ptah - November 16, 2011

I’m afraid I don’t remember the character arcs in enough detail to have intelligent commentary on most of this, but there’s one point I want to respond to.

With Floe, the issue wasn’t that she was a stereotypical girly-girl who became a man instead of a woman. The issue was that she was a stereotypical girly-girl who, after becoming a man, had every well-established “girlish” part of her characterization erased and replaced with stereotypical “manly” traits that appeared out of nowhere. They had a good, affirming start with “a girlish person can decide to identify as male,” and then flubbed the next step, which is “a person living as male can still go on being girlish.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: